Ice cream · Downtown Northampton, Amherst and Northampton

Herrell's Ice Cream

Herrell's Ice Cream: Ice cream in Downtown Northampton, Amherst and Northampton. Order: A scoop with a smoosh-in.

Chef's pick Where to eat ice cream with mix-ins Stop on the Amherst and Northampton food walk

What to order

A scoop with a smoosh-in

Any flavor with a smoosh-in

Why go

The shop of the man who started mix-ins, in Northampton for about 45 years.

Steve Herrell began mixing candy into ice cream in the 1970s; the Northampton shop has been here about 45 years, with a second shop in North Amherst's Mill District.

Address: 8 Old South St, Northampton, MA
Neighborhood: Downtown Northampton

Add to Chef Amazing Open in Maps See it in the Amherst and Northampton guide

Seen in Wikipedia, WWLP, Amherst Indy

Also nearby in Downtown Northampton

Mala Pot & Grill Pinocchio's Pizzeria Jake's Amherst Farmers Market Amherst Oyster Bar Antonio's Pizza Atkins Farms Country Market Black Sheep Deli

Plan my Amherst and Northampton food trip Where to eat in Amherst and Northampton

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Amherst and Northampton · 250 food markets