New York pizza by the slice · Lower East Side / Chinatown border, New York City

Scarr's Pizza

Scarr's Pizza: New York pizza by the slice in Lower East Side / Chinatown border, New York City. Critics: 87% liked it, from 5 reviews (2022 to 2025). Order: Plain slice; the Hotboi (pepperoni, jalapeño, hot honey) is the one reviewers keep recommending.

Chef's pickWhere to eat new york sliceStop on the New York City food walk

What to order

Plain slice; the Hotboi (pepperoni, jalapeño, hot honey) is the one reviewers keep recommending.

Plain slice or pepperoni with jalapeños

Why go

Opened 2016 and run by Scarr Pimentel, with organic ingredients and New York-style pies. Reviews from August to October 2026 mention loud music and uneven service, but the slice is the draw.

Old-school slice made with house-milled flour; a modern benchmark for the classic fold.

What the critics say

Critics: 87% liked it, from 5 reviews (2022 to 2025). Written up by Time Out (World's Best Pizza ranking) 2025, Time Out (World's Best Pizzas 2025) 2025, The Infatuation 2024.

Address
35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Neighborhood
Lower East Side / Chinatown border
Price
$
Hours
Mon-Wed, Sun 11:30am-11pm; Thu 11:30am-midnight; Fri-Sat 11:30am-2am (per OpenTable) (as listed; check before you go)
Add to Chef Amazing Open in MapsSee it in the New York City guide

Seen in OpenTable, tastingtable.com

More places in New York City

2nd Ave DeliA&A Bake & Doubles ShopAskaAtomixB&H DairyBalthazarBarney GreengrassBlue Sky Deli (Hajji's)
Plan my New York City food tripWhere to eat in New York City

Researched October 23, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · New York City · 250 food markets