Seafood · Cortez, Sarasota

Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant

Name: Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant
Address: Sarasota, United States
Price range: $$

Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant: Seafood in Cortez, Sarasota. Order: Grouper sandwich on the dock, and the grouper Reuben when it is a special.

Local favorite Chef's pick Where to eat grouper sandwich Where to eat fresh local catch Sandwich shop

What to order

Grouper sandwich on the dock, and the grouper Reuben when it is a special

Grouper sandwich, or the grouper Reuben when it is a special

Why go

A fish market and dockside counter in the old fishing village of Cortez. The Herald-Tribune put its grouper sandwich among the region's best, and it made USA Today's Restaurants of the Year list.

A fish market with a dockside counter in a working fishing village north of Longboat Key.

Neighborhood: Cortez
Price: $$

Add to Chef Amazing Open in Maps See it in the Sarasota guide

Seen in Herald-Tribune (PressReader), Sarasota Magazine, I Love the Burg (USA Today Restaurants of the Year)

Also nearby in Cortez

Tide Tables Columbia Restaurant Focaccia Sandwich + Bakery Gelato-Go Ginny's & Jane E's Lucky 8 Made in Rome Organic Gelato Main Street Creamery

Plan my Sarasota food trip Where to eat in Sarasota

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sarasota · 250 food markets