Amish home cooking · Pinecraft, Sarasota

Yoder's Restaurant

Yoder's Restaurant: Amish home cooking in Pinecraft, Sarasota. Order: Peanut butter cream pie with whipped cream.

Local favoriteChef's pickWhere to eat pinecraft amish pieBreakfast

What to order

Peanut butter cream pie with whipped cream

A slice of cream pie

Why go

An Amish family restaurant in Pinecraft that has turned 50, baking up to 100 pies a day in at least 25 kinds.

Fifty years of Amish cooking and pies in Pinecraft, with Pie Craft Coffee Co. selling mini pies in the market next door.

Address
3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota
Neighborhood
Pinecraft
Price
$
Hours
Closed Sundays (as listed; check before you go)
Add to Chef Amazing Open in MapsSee it in the Sarasota guide

Seen in Visit Sarasota, Edible Sarasota, Atlas Obscura, Yahoo News (Go For the Food)

More places in Sarasota

Columbia RestaurantFocaccia Sandwich + BakeryGelato-GoGinny's & Jane E'sLucky 8Made in Rome Organic GelatoMain Street CreameryMar Vista Dockside
Plan my Sarasota food tripWhere to eat in Sarasota

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sarasota · 250 food markets