American tavern · Sag Harbor, The Hamptons

Sag Harbor Tavern

Name: Sag Harbor Tavern
Address: 26 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, The Hamptons, United States
Price range: $$$$

Sag Harbor Tavern: American tavern in Sag Harbor, The Hamptons. Order: The burger, cooked medium rare, and the wedge salad.

Chef's pick Stop on the The Hamptons food walk Sandwich shop

What to order

The burger, cooked medium rare, and the wedge salad

The burger, medium rare, and a wedge salad to split.

Why go

Billy Durney's East End sister to Red Hook Tavern, opened in 2024 in the old American Legion building on Bay Street. Reviewers praise the burger; some seafood starters get mixed notes. Chef Amazing's founder is a partner here.

Billy Durney's sister to Red Hook Tavern, in the old American Legion building. Chef Amazing's founder is a partner here.

Address: 26 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Neighborhood: Sag Harbor
Price: $$$$
Hours: Dinner; book on OpenTable. Phone (631) 899-4078. (as listed; check before you go)

Add to Chef Amazing Open in Maps See it in the The Hamptons guide

Seen in The Infatuation, Crain's Currency, Taste (Substack), James Lane Post, OpenTable

Also nearby in Sag Harbor

Harbor Market and Kitchen Babe's The Bar at The American Hotel Beacon

Plan my The Hamptons food trip Where to eat in The Hamptons

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · The Hamptons · 250 food markets