Best of New York City

The best pizza in New York City

Start with Don Antonio in Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan for la Montanara Classica: fried dough, tomato, smoked mozzarella, Lucky Charlie in Bushwick, Brooklyn for classic Pie and Una Pizza Napoletana in Lower East Side, Manhattan for margherita. Here are all 12, with what to get at each.

12 places · mostly in Little Italy · Updated November 7, 2026

Don Antonio
Don Antonio · Photo: Don Antonio
  1. Don AntonioDon AntonioHell's Kitchen, Manhattan · Neapolitan pizza

    Get: La Montanara Classica: fried dough, tomato, smoked mozzarella

    The dough is flash-fried, then finished in the oven: a Naples street classic most New Yorkers have never tried.

  2. Lucky CharlieLucky CharlieBushwick, Brooklyn · Coal-oven pizza

    Get: Classic Pie

    Nino Coniglio fires New York's oldest coal oven back up. The plain pie is the reason to go.

  3. Una Pizza NapoletanaUna Pizza NapoletanaLower East Side, Manhattan · Neapolitan pizza

    Get: Margherita

    Anthony Mangieri's short menu, often called the best pizza in the world. The margherita is why.

  4. CeresLittle Italy · Pizza

    Get: 'Nduja Pie: 'nduja, burrata and aged balsamic

    Fine-dining alumni bake baguette-style crusts in a tiny oven: crackly outside, airy inside. Pricey, and worth it.

  5. Pizza Studio TamakiEast Village · Neapolitan pizza

    Get: 5 Formaggi

    The first US shop from Tokyo's PST. Five cheeses on a light, crisp-chewy crust.

  6. Stretch PizzaFlatiron, Manhattan · Pizza

    Get: Everything Bagel

    Wylie Dufresne's pizzeria. A New York bagel with everything, turned into a pie.

  7. Scarr's PizzaLower East Side / Chinatown border · New York slice

    Get: Plain slice; the Hotboi (pepperoni, jalapeño, hot honey) is the one reviewers keep recommending

    Laid-back Lower East Side pizzeria milling its own flour, known for thin crispy slices and a cool soundtrack.

  8. Joe's PizzaJoe's PizzaGreenwich Village, Manhattan · NY pizza slice

    Get: A plain cheese slice, folded

    The classic New York slice since 1975. Classic Greenwich Village slice shop since 1975, known for simple, foldable New York style cheese slices.

  9. LucaliLucaliCarroll Gardens, Brooklyn

    Get: A plain pie with basil and the calzone. Bring your own wine

    Candlelit Brooklyn pizza that celebrities and Instagram made impossible to get into.

  10. RubirosaRubirosaNoLita · Italian-American pizza

    Get: the Tie-Dye pizza, the vodka pizza, the rigatoni

    Order: the vodka pie and a red-sauce pasta. Easier to walk in at lunch.

  11. L'Industrie PizzeriaLittle Italy · New York slice

    Get: Thin, slightly charred slice topped with fresh burrata that melts into the pie

    The slice shop that took over every food feed: thin, crisp, burrata added after the oven.

  12. Prince Street PizzaNolita · New York slice

    Get: Spicy Spring square slice

Keep these in Chef Amazing

Save the places you want and Chef remembers them for your trip: what to order, how to book, on a map with everything else you love in New York City. Free.

Ask Chef for morePlan my New York City food tripPlan it with your group

The best pizza in New York City: questions people ask

Where is the best pizza in New York City?

Chef Amazing’s picks start with Don Antonio (Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan), Lucky Charlie (Bushwick, Brooklyn) and Una Pizza Napoletana (Lower East Side, Manhattan). All 12 places are on this page with what to get, where they are and a map.

What should I order?

At Don Antonio, get la Montanara Classica: fried dough, tomato, smoked mozzarella. At Lucky Charlie, get classic Pie. At Una Pizza Napoletana, get margherita. At Ceres, get 'Nduja Pie: 'nduja, burrata and aged balsamic.

Which neighborhood is best for pizza in New York City?

Most of these are in Little Italy. The map on this page shows every one, numbered like the list.

How does Chef Amazing pick these?

From Chef Amazing’s city guide and lists for New York City: the places critics, chefs and locals keep recommending, checked and kept current, with what to order at each. Nobody pays to be on them.

More in New York City

Where to eat in New York CityThe New York City food mapBagel with loxBaked roast pork bunBakeries and pastryBreakfast and brunchBurgersChopped cheeseIce creamNew York slicePastrami on ryeSandwichesCelebrity restaurantsLocal restaurantsMichelin-starred restaurantsNew restaurantsRomantic restaurantsNew York City food calendar

Pizza in other cities

ChicagoMiamiNaplesNew HavenPhiladelphiaRomeSan Francisco

Places change: check hours before you go. Pins come from addresses and OpenStreetMap and can be a little off. Updated November 7, 2026.

Chef Amazing · Best of every city · Food cities · Food maps