Bakery · Bay Street, Sag Harbor, Sag Harbor

Carissa's The Bakery

Carissa's The Bakery: Bakery in Bay Street, Sag Harbor, Sag Harbor. Order: A loaf of the European-style bread and a pastry; pies in the fall.

James Beard Award semifinalist, Outstanding Bakery (2025)Local favoriteWhere to eat donuts and bakery breadStop on the Sag Harbor food walkBreakfast

What to order

A loaf of the European-style bread and a pastry; pies in the fall

A pastry to share and a loaf to take home.

Why go

Long Island's only James Beard semifinalist in 2025. The bakery started at farmers markets; its Sag Harbor shop is on Bay Street.

A 2025 James Beard semifinalist for Outstanding Bakery. Goop lists the Sag Harbor shop at 3 Bay St.

Address
3 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Neighborhood
Bay Street, Sag Harbor
Price
$$
Hours
Hours not in our sources; check before going. (as listed; check before you go)
Add to Chef Amazing Open in MapsSee it in the Sag Harbor guide

Seen in East Hampton Star, Greater Long Island, Goop Sag Harbor guide

More places in Sag Harbor

Babe'sBeaconBig OlafCavaniola's GourmetCruustDopo La SpiaggiaGoldberg'sGrindstone Coffee & Donuts
Plan my Sag Harbor food tripWhere to eat in Sag Harbor

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sag Harbor · 250 food markets