Sag Harbor is an old whaling village on Long Island's East End, with a Main Street that runs down to Long Wharf and the marina. You can park once and walk to a bakery, a donut counter, an eight-seat diner car, a tavern burger and dinner on the water. It is busiest from Memorial Day to September; in winter many places shorten hours or close for weeks.
Sag Harbor at a glance
What to eat
Tavern burger; Diner breakfast; Donuts and bakery bread; Harbor seafood dinner; Deli sandwich for the beach.
When to go
Best: June–September. Also good: May and October. Hardest: January–March.
Top tables
This guide lists 1 award-winning restaurant, starting with Carissa's The Bakery.
Where locals eat
Local favorites off the prestige lists include Carissa's The Bakery, Grindstone Coffee & Donuts, Sagtown Coffee and Schiavoni's Market.
Markets
Harbor Market and Kitchen and Cavaniola's Gourmet.
1 award-winning10 local favorites2 hot right now2 markets7 walking tour stops10 chef's picks5 sandwich shops5 romantic dinners5 breakfast spots3 new openings12 dish spots
Food walking tour: Main Street, Long Wharf and Bay Street: a morning in Sag Harbor5.0 hours on foot, 7 stops, in eating order. Add the whole tour to your trip, then give it a day.
Going with a group?Give Chef your dates and hotel and he drafts every meal. Then send the group one link: they heart what they'd go to, add their own, and see the morning each table opens.
Sag Harbor is one walkable village. These are the tables people book and the counters locals walk to; check winter hours before you go.
The well-known five
Sag Harbor Tavern
Bay Street
American tavern$$$$
Order: The burger, cooked medium rare, and the wedge salad
Billy Durney's East End sister to Red Hook Tavern, opened in 2024 in the old American Legion building on Bay Street, blocks from Main Street. Reviewers praise the burger; some seafood starters get mixed notes. Chef Amazing's founder is a partner here.
Best for: burger night · Reserve: book ahead · Hours: Dinner; book on OpenTable. Phone (631) 899-4078.
Michael Nolan, a third-generation Sag Harbor native who co-founded Fresno in East Hampton, took the old Vin Sur Vingt space at 29 Main St; chef Jesus Gonzales.
New places change fast. “Provisional” means a guide or directory lists it as new but we have not confirmed the opening date. Check hours and book ahead before you go.
Memorable breakfasts in Sag Harbor
Five places chosen for the food, the room, the history or the local character. In no ranked order.
Babe's
Division Street
Order: Babe's classic pancakes
An eight-seat diner car that opened in April 2026 and draws lines for its pancakes.
Picks come from romantic-dinner lists on booking and review sites. Confirm dinner service, menus and availability before you book.
Food walking tour
Main Street, Long Wharf and Bay Street: a morning in Sag Harbor
Donuts, a bakery, a market sandwich, cheese, pancakes and a waffle cone, all on foot.
Start 08:30 at Grindstone Coffee & Donuts, 7A Main StTime 5.0 hoursDistance about 2.0 kmBest days A Friday to Sunday from late May to September, when Big Olaf is open and every stop keeps full hours.
The East End is car country, but Sag Harbor village is small enough to walk: Main Street runs down to Long Wharf, Bay Street runs along the marina, and Division Street runs parallel to Main. Walking times below are short and approximate.
Pacing: Share everything up to Babe's so there is room for pancakes, and book Sag Harbor Tavern (26 Bay St) for a burger at dinner.
Plan B: If Babe's line is long, take the Schiavoni's sandwich to Long Wharf and come back to Babe's at 7am the next day. Off season, swap Big Olaf for a drink at The Bar at The American Hotel.
Avoid: November to April, when Big Olaf is closed and other hours shrink; summer Saturdays after 10am at Babe's.
Bring: Cash for Big Olaf, a tote for cheese and bread, and a dinner booking at Sag Harbor Tavern if you are staying.
Skip it if: Skip it if you want ocean beaches and lobster shacks; those are a drive away in Amagansett and Montauk.
Ends at: Big Olaf, Long Wharf.
Walking times and distances are approximate, and opening hours change: confirm before you go.
Hot right now in Sag Harbor
What people are lining up for and posting about this month. Entries expire after about four months unless they are reported again.
Always a lineLast confirmed 2025
Big Olaf
Long Wharf · $
The thing: a homemade waffle cone
The line: Out the door on summer nights; it moves fast
Seasonal rooms open in May (Beacon on May 13 in 2026; Le Bilboquet limited in May and June, daily from July) and the wharf is busiest July to September. September keeps warm days with easier tables. From November to April many places cut hours or close for weeks.
In season
Peconic Bay scallopsNov–DecState waters open the first Monday in November. Recent harvests have been poor, so ask before you count on them.
Farm-stand corn and tomatoesJul–SepLocal corn from mid-July; late August is the fullest week at the stands.
Thanksgiving to-go dishesNovHarbor Market and Kitchen takes holiday orders; order a week or more ahead.
Food events
Hamptons Restaurant Week (spring)AprPrix-fixe menus as the season opens; Sag Harbor restaurants take part. Check Dan's Papers for dates.
HarborFestSepThe village harbor festival on Long Wharf; it was September 19-20 in 2026.
Hamptons Restaurant Week (fall)OctA second prix-fixe run after the summer; 2027 dates not announced.
Closures to plan around
Big Olaf is cash only and seasonal; Goop listed Friday to Sunday hours.
Babe's is walk-in only by day; dinner is booked on Resy.
Beacon and Le Bilboquet are seasonal.
The Corner Bar at 1 Main Street closed in February 2026 and had not reopened by November 2026.
Estia's Little Kitchen closed in April 2026.
From published guides and tourism boards. Months are our mapping of how guides describe the seasons; 2027 event dates are expected, not confirmed. Prices come from single sources of varying age, so treat them as a rough guide. Compare cities by month
Every place we have in Sag Harbor (21)
Search or filter, then tap Add to my trip. Places you add go straight into your trip planner.
Carissa's The BakeryAward-winningLocal favoritesWalking tour stopsDish spotsBreakfast spotsBay Street, Sag Harbor · James Beard Award semifinalist, Outstanding Bakery (2025) · Bakery · $$
Big OlafLocal favoritesWalking tour stopsHot right nowLong Wharf · street-food
Cavaniola's GourmetLocal favoritesMarketsWalking tour stopsDish spotsSandwich shopsDivision Street · classic
Goldberg'sLocal favoritesBreakfast spotsMain Street · classic
Grindstone Coffee & DonutsLocal favoritesWalking tour stopsHot right nowDish spotsBreakfast spotsMain Street · bakery
Harbor Market and KitchenLocal favoritesMarketsDish spotsSandwich shopsDivision Street · cafe
Sagtown CoffeeLocal favoritesMain Street · cafe
Schiavoni's MarketLocal favoritesWalking tour stopsDish spotsSandwich shopsMain Street · family-run
SenLocal favoritesChef's picksRomantic dinnersMain Street · family-run
The Bar at The American HotelLocal favoritesMain Street · bar
Babe'sWalking tour stopsDish spotsChef's picksBreakfast spotsNew openingsSag Harbor · diner
Long WharfWalking tour stopsSag Harbor · walk
BeaconDish spotsChef's picksRomantic dinnersWest Water Street · Harbor seafood dinner
Dopo La SpiaggiaDish spotsChef's picksBay Street · Harbor seafood dinner
Le BilboquetDish spotsChef's picksRomantic dinnersMarina · Le Bilboquet's Cajun chicken
Lulu Kitchen & BarDish spotsChef's picksMain Street · Tavern burger
MiracleChef's picksBreakfast spotsNew openingsMain Street · Weekend brunch
Sag Harbor TavernDish spotsChef's picksSandwich shopsBay Street · Tavern burger
The American HotelChef's picksRomantic dinnersMain Street · Romantic dinner
The Bell & AnchorDish spotsChef's picksRomantic dinnersNoyac · Harbor seafood dinner
CruustSandwich shopsNew openingsMain Street · Cafe sandwiches
Secret discoveries
Locally loved places that are not on the big prestige lists.
bakery
Carissa's The Bakery
Bay Street · $$
Order: A loaf of the European-style bread and a pastry; pies in the fall
A 2025 James Beard semifinalist for Outstanding Bakery. Goop lists the Sag Harbor shop at 3 Bay St.
Awards come from the guides named on each listing (James Beard 2025 + Infatuation, Goop and East End press 2025-2026). Researched November 7, 2026. Restaurants change; confirm hours, reservations and current stars before you go. Some addresses, phone numbers and websites come from OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), so call ahead to confirm. Local favorites are editorial picks, not rankings.
