American, French · Main Street, Sag Harbor
The American Hotel
The American Hotel: American, French in Main Street, Sag Harbor. Order: Dinner in the dining room, or a drink at the bar.
What to order
Dinner in the dining room, or a drink at the bar
Why go
A Main Street hotel restaurant that Dan's Papers marked at 50 years in 2022, and one of the few rooms that serves holiday meals.
- Neighborhood
- Main Street
- Price
- $$$$
Seen in Goop, Dan's Papers, South Forker
Also nearby in Main Street
Grindstone Coffee & DonutsSagtown CoffeeSchiavoni's MarketGoldberg'sSenThe Bar at The American HotelLulu Kitchen & BarMiracle
Plan my Sag Harbor food tripWhere to eat in Sag Harbor
Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.
Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sag Harbor · 250 food markets