‹ The Chocolate Chip 25 › New York
No. 2 of the world's best chocolate chip cookies
Red Gate Bakery
No. 2The cookie to get
The choco-toffee cookie
A little toffee in the dough, shards of bittersweet chocolate and Maldon salt on top. It was the unanimous winner of The Infatuation's blind test of 32 New York cookies in October 2026.
Why it's on the list
Make one at home
Giant chocolate chip walnut cookies
Chef's own six-ounce cookie, crisp at the edges and gooey in the middle.
The pin shows the neighborhood; Directions finds the shop.
Is this your shop?
You're No. 2 on the Chocolate Chip 25. Make your card above (it downloads, or opens your share sheet on a phone), post it, and tag @chefamazing. Something changed? Write to hello@chefamazing.com.
More on the 25
Checked open November 13, 2026. Hours and flavors change; check before you cross town.
Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.