American tavern · Bay Street, Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor Tavern

Sag Harbor Tavern: American tavern in Bay Street, Sag Harbor. Order: The burger, cooked medium rare, and the wedge salad.

Chef's pickWhere to eat tavern burgerSandwich shop

What to order

The burger, cooked medium rare, and the wedge salad

The burger, medium rare

Why go

Billy Durney's East End sister to Red Hook Tavern, opened in 2024 in the old American Legion building on Bay Street, blocks from Main Street. Reviewers praise the burger; some seafood starters get mixed notes. Chef Amazing's founder is a partner here.

The Red Hook Tavern burger, made on Bay Street. Chef Amazing's founder is a partner here.

Address
26 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Neighborhood
Bay Street
Price
$$$$
Hours
Dinner; book on OpenTable. Phone (631) 899-4078. (as listed; check before you go)
Add to Chef Amazing Open in MapsSee it in the Sag Harbor guide

Seen in The Infatuation, Goop, Taste (Substack), OpenTable, Crain's Currency

Also nearby in Bay Street

Dopo La SpiaggiaBabe'sBeaconBig OlafCarissa's The BakeryCavaniola's GourmetCruustGoldberg's
Plan my Sag Harbor food tripWhere to eat in Sag Harbor

Researched November 7, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.

Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sag Harbor · 250 food markets