Amalfi Coast Italian, seafood · West Water Street, Sag Harbor
Zagara at Faraway Sag Harbor
Zagara at Faraway Sag Harbor: Amalfi Coast Italian, seafood in West Water Street, Sag Harbor. Order: Peconic oysters, the tomato salad, lobster arrabbiata, lemon risotto.
What to order
Peconic oysters, the tomato salad, lobster arrabbiata, lemon risotto
Peconic oysters, the signature tomato salad, lobster arrabbiata, lemon risotto
Why go
The Amalfi-coast dining room in the new Faraway hotel, which reopened the old Baron's Cove on the harbor in summer 2026. Chef Jarad McCarroll came from Montauk Yacht Club; Galavante named it one of the hardest Hamptons tables of the summer.
New in 2026 inside Faraway Sag Harbor, the reborn Baron's Cove on the water. Chef Jarad McCarroll (ex-Montauk Yacht Club) cooks East End seafood the Amalfi way; it was one of the summer's hardest Hamptons reservations. Start or end at the lobby bar for oysters and Champagne.
- Address
- 31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Neighborhood
- West Water Street
- Price
- $$$$
- Hours
- Off-season: Thursday to Saturday, 5pm to 10pm. Lobby bar and patio daily from 11:30am (to 11pm Thursday to Saturday). Check the hotel's site for summer hours. (as listed; check before you go)
- Website
- farawaysagharbor.com
Seen in Faraway Sag Harbor, Faraway Sag Harbor (Eat & Drink, hours), Behind The Hedges, Galavante, Cultured, Resy
Also nearby in West Water Street
Researched November 8, 2026 from the sources linked above. Places change; confirm hours and reservations before you go.
Chef Amazing · Will Travel for Food · Sag Harbor · 250 food markets