Lists › Sarasota

Where to get ice cream in Sarasota

The places for gelato, soft serve and a proper scoop. Check hours before you go: plenty slow down or close in winter.

5 places in Sarasota · by Chef Amazing · updated November 8, 2026

Save this list in Chef Amazing Where to eat in Sarasota: the full guide
  1. 1

    Settimi's Gelato

    Ice cream · St. Armands Circle (367 St. Armands Circle)

    Get: Pistachio gelato

  2. 2

    Made in Rome Organic Gelato

    Ice cream · Siesta Key Village (5204 Ocean Blvd)

    Get: Hazelnut or pistachio, from 20-plus organic flavors

  3. 3

    Gelato-Go

    Ice cream · Downtown (14 S. Orange Ave)

    Get: A cup on the walk down Main Street

  4. 4

    Main Street Creamery

    Ice cream · Downtown (1359 Main St)

    Get: Yoder's strawberry or the non-dairy toasted coconut

  5. 5

    Big Olaf Creamery

    Ice cream · St. Armands Circle

    Get: Strawberry, made in Pinecraft

Keep the places you love

Chef Amazing remembers every place you've eaten, booked or been told about, by city, and tells you what to order. Save this list, add your own, and send it to a friend.

Save this list, free

Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.

Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms