The Pickle 25 · No. 3 of 25

  1. Organic Garlic Dill Pickles from Real Pickles No.3Good Food Award winnerPhoto: Real Pickles

    Dill and sour

    Organic Garlic Dill Pickles

    From Real Pickles · Greenfield, Massachusetts · @realpickles

    Fermented○○○No heat

    A worker-owned co-op in western Massachusetts. Organic Northeast vegetables, salt and time; everything is fermented, nothing is pasteurized, so the jar is alive.

    This is what a pickle tasted like before vinegar took over. Clean, salty, sour, a lot of garlic. Keep it cold; it's still working.

    Eat it withA grilled cheeseBoiled potatoes with butter and dillSmoked fish on toast

    Chef's quick version

    Fermented garlic dills

    20 min, then 4 to 7 days · makes 1 quart · The same method as the barrel men, made smaller and garlic-heavy. Keep the jar cool (65 to 72°F) and the pickles under the brine and you can't go wrong.

    Save to my recipes

    You need

    • 1½ lb (680 g) small pickling cucumbers
    • 4 cups (950 ml) filtered water
    • 2 tbsp (36 g) fine sea salt
    • 10 garlic cloves, peeled and halved
    • 2 dill heads or a handful of dill fronds and stems
    • 1 tsp black peppercorns
    • 2 grape or oak leaves, or 1 black tea bag (for crunch)

    How to make it

    1. Soak the cucumbers in ice water for 30 minutes so they firm up. Trim the blossom ends.
    2. Dissolve the salt in the water.
    3. Layer the leaves, garlic, dill and peppercorns with the cucumbers in a clean jar, packed tight.
    4. Cover with brine and weigh them down so they stay under.
    5. Leave at cool room temperature. Bubbles and cloudy brine by day 2 or 3 are good signs.
    6. Taste from day 4. When they are sour enough, refrigerate. They keep getting better for a week in the fridge.

    Chef's own quick version, in our words. It isn't Real Pickles's recipe: for the real thing, order the jar.

See all 25

Real Pickles: your card

Made the list? Here's a card to post, and one sized for a story. Tap one to save it.

Next on the list

← No. 2 McClure'sNo. 4 Mama Lil's →Build a pickle plate

Know a pickle we missed?

Somebody making one jar, really well, in small batches? Tell us at hello@chefamazing.com and we'll go taste it.

More lists like this

The Small Batch 25The Freezer 25Ingredient of the weekThe 25 best soup recipesThe Hot 100 food creators

Real Pickles didn't pay to be here. Order goes straight to their shop. The quick version is Chef's own, in our words.

Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.

Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms