Thanksgiving · The Trust List No. 1
Thanksgiving is almost here and the internet is shouting. These are the people I'd actually hand the job to. Every one of them made the thing I'm pointing you to: a turkey, a side, a pie, a whole make-ahead plan, a table. Tap through to theirs, then follow them, because they'll be good next year too.
BB
The Food Lab's turkey, for anyone short on oven time: cut out the backbone, flatten it, 450°F, and it's done in about 80 minutes, breast and thighs finishing together.
Crisp-skinned butterflied roast turkey ›
He steams the bird in a covered pot, then roasts it just to brown the skin, with nicked joints so the legs finish with the breast. The steaming water becomes your gravy stock.
“The steaming gives a lot of moisture to the meat, and the roasting browns the skin.” thecookscook.com
Steamed-then-roasted turkey ›
His Thanksgiving turkey never goes in the oven. He brines it, grill-roasts it over a little mesquite smoke and serves it with red chile adobo instead of gravy. If your oven is full, this is your answer.
Mesquite-smoked grilled turkey ›
For the table that's had the same turkey for 20 years: grapefruit, orange, lemon and lime juice with ras el hanout. Familiar bird, completely new flavor.
Moroccan-spiced turkey ›
A brine of orange, maple, honey and whole spices, then goose fat and maple while it roasts. Her warning is the one everyone needs: most turkeys are overcooked.
Spiced and superjuicy roast turkey ›
Every table needs one thing that isn't beige. Hers is raw Brussels sprouts shaved thin with lemon, pecorino and pine nuts. No oven, and it's better after it sits.
“I bring this salad to my family's Thanksgiving dinner every year.” loveandlemons.com
Shaved Brussels sprout salad ›
Toasted bread, onion and celery cooked soft in butter, good stock, one egg and a little yellow box of Bell's Seasoning. It freezes, so you can make it this weekend.
“Hands down, it is my favorite part of the Thanksgiving meal every year.” alexandracooks.com
Classic bread stuffing ›
Her mom brings it every year: buttery mashed sweet potatoes under a brown sugar and pecan top that bakes into something close to a cookie.
“This is a recipe that my mom has been making for years... there is a reason it has become a mainstay at Thanksgiving.” pinchofyum.com
Sweet potato casserole with brown sugar pecan topping ›
Jenn trained as a chef, and her gravy has one chef's move: onions cooked slowly in butter before the flour goes in. A spoon of Cognac finishes it, in 35 minutes while the turkey rests.
“This is my go-to turkey gravy recipe, and I make it every year for Thanksgiving.” onceuponachef.com
Turkey gravy with Cognac ›
Parboiled, shaken with semolina until shaggy, dropped into very hot fat. For the family that says they don't need potatoes and then eats every one.
Truly crunchy roast potatoes ›
Her Thanksgiving side from last November: baby carrots baked in brown butter and shallots with capers, under Gruyère and brown butter breadcrumbs.
Crunchy brown butter baked carrots ›
The custardy, sliceable Southern kind, four cheeses with smoked cheddar on top. Monique says the smoked cheddar is a must.
Southern baked mac and cheese ›
Five ingredients, ten minutes, cooked in a smoking wok while the turkey rests. The green vegetable nobody leaves on the plate.
Garlic green beans ›
For the vegetarian at the table, and honestly for the mashed potatoes: dried porcini, rosemary and thyme, blended smooth. The meat eaters go for it too.
Mushroom gravy (vegan) ›
The stuffing most of us grew up on, done right. Her secret is to soak it until it's very wet before it bakes, so it's never dry.
Sausage stuffing ›
The roll Boston's Parker House hotel made famous, each one folded around a buttery pocket. Potato flakes in the dough keep it soft. If you bake one thing from scratch, bake these.
Parker House rolls ›
She wrote the book on pie, literally. New this month: a sweet potato pie under a toasted brown sugar marshmallow layer, 'a nod to the classic dish often served at Thanksgiving, but pie-ified.' It comes with a gluten-free crust option.
“a nod to the classic dish often served at Thanksgiving, but pie-ified” erinjeannemcdowell.com
Sweet potato marshmallow pie ›
The pastry chef you can watch: her sweet potato pie video takes you through the whole pie, crust to filling, in 25 minutes, so you see exactly what each step should look like.
The sweet potato pie every Thanksgiving table needs (video) ›
The patron saint of a calm Thanksgiving. Her make-ahead menu has the turkey and gravy going 'directly from the oven to the table,' and a mushroom and leek bread pudding instead of stuffing the bird.
“classic flavors but with the volume turned way up so you can serve a delicious Thanksgiving feast with less stress” barefootcontessa.com
Make-ahead Thanksgiving dinner ›
The most beautiful tables on Instagram, and her first rule is keep it simple: a controlled palette taken from the food on the menu. She set her Thanksgiving table in 15 minutes.
“Setting this table took me all of 15 minutes and then it was on to the kitchen!” eye-swoon.com
Thanksgiving table setting rules to live by ›
She didn't grow up with Thanksgiving and loves it anyway, which is why her table ideas feel fresh. Her plan covers the table, what to cook and the shortcuts that make it feel effortless.
“My excitement levels are HIGH. Disproportionately high” smcalpine.substack.com
A plan for Thanksgiving (The Dolce Vita Diaries) ›
Start with a minimal table and put the texture on top: a runner, napkins and the centerpiece. Mix old pieces with new. Easy to copy with what you already own.
“I love dressing up my Thanksgiving table with pieces both old and new.” magnolia.com
My Thanksgiving table ›
The craft-table genius. Her golden Thanksgiving: spray-paint pine cones and dried corn gold ('GIY, Gild It Yourself') and draw place cards in gold pen on burgundy card stock.
“as I like to say, GIY (Gild It Yourself)” darcymillerdesigns.com
A golden Thanksgiving ›
For a table that makes people smile. Her whimsical Thanksgiving table is set with a collection of Thanksgiving paper goods she made with the party shop Bonjour Fête.
A whimsical Thanksgiving table with Bonjour Fête ›
The designer behind Firmdale's hotels says skip the all-brown table: colored glass, patterned dessert plates, orange tapers, and a little imperfection.
“Thanksgiving doesn't need to be all about pumpkins and browns; it can sing with unexpected brightness.” kitkemp.com
How to set your Thanksgiving table, Kit Kemp style ›Send them this. One of these 25 will save their Thursday.
Every pick is a real, active creator whose Instagram account we checked on 2026-11-20. Each card links to that creator's own Thanksgiving work, and any quote is word for word from the page it links to. The cooks come from the Thanksgiving pieces we've already researched (ten chefs' turkeys, the 25 essential sides, the side I always bring); the pie, the plan and the table we read this week. Every photo is the creator's own and says whose it is. Nobody paid to be here.
Who do you trust with Thanksgiving? Tell me at hello@chefamazing.com. They might be in the next one.
Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.
Researched and published by Chef Amazing, from our own stories, this year’s critics and food press, and a check that each place is open. Nobody pays to be on our lists: how we pick. Spot something wrong? Tell us and we fix it.