Where to eat in Bayfield, Wisconsin

Priceline

Lake Superior whitefish

A Lake Superior fishing town where the whitefish comes off the boat and the livers go on toast.

Priceline's 2027 Where to Next?: Among the five domestic picks on Priceline's 2027 Where to Next, for year-over-year growth in searches. (Time Out, Priceline 2027)

The dish: Lake Superior whitefish

Broiled or fried fresh whitefish, with the old local order of whitefish livers on toast. The best one is at Greunke's Restaurant.

Where to eat in Bayfield

Restaurant · the best lake superior whitefish

Greunke's Restaurant

First Street, Bayfield

Get: Whitefish livers, a fish boil and a fresh fruit pie

Credited as the first Bayfield restaurant to serve whitefish livers.

Source: Bayfield Chamber dining sheet, July 2025

Restaurant

Pier Plaza

Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield

Get: Broiled Lake Superior whitefish in white wine

Its Summer 2026 menu lists whitefish dishes.

Source: Pier Plaza on Toast, summer 2026 menu

Restaurant

Manypenny Bistro

Manypenny Ave, Bayfield

Get: Breakfast or dinner, American with a Turkish twist

A town favorite recommended in Bayfield's 2026 guide.

Source: Bayfield Chamber, Valentine's weekend guide (2026)

Bar

Portside Bar & Restaurant

Port Superior marina

Get: Lunch or dinner with a harbor view

Upstairs restaurant and docks at the marina clubhouse.

Source: Town of Bayfield, 2026-2027 liquor license applications

Market

Chequamegon Food Co-op

Bayfield

Get: Local provisions for a picnic

The town grocery for local food and a picnic lunch.

Source: Bayfield Chamber dining sheet, Nov 2025

When to goSeptember and early October for the Apple Fest harvest and fall color.

Good to knowMany Bayfield places are seasonal and close after October.

Getting thereTell your concierge where you're flying from and we'll plan the eating around it.

Go, and let us handle the food

Book Bayfield, Wisconsin with us and a food concierge comes with it: a call before you go, the hard tables asked for through the restaurant's own line with a backup for each, markets and classes, a what-to-order sheet, and a text line while you're there. A real person writes back within a day; nothing is charged now.

Ask Chef about Bayfield, Wisconsin

Also on the 2027 lists, nearby

Madison, WisconsinEat: Friday fish fry

Springfield-style cashew chicken

Southern Ozarks, Missouri and ArkansasEat: Springfield-style cashew chicken

Jumbo lump crab cake

Baltimore and MarylandEat: Jumbo lump crab cake

All 46 destinations

Every place was checked open on November 11, 2026, from the source under it. On Priceline's 2027 Where to Next?. Something changed? Write to hello@chefamazing.com. Tourism board? Post this guide free.

Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.

Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms