The best lobster roll in the Hamptons
Chunks of cold lobster dressed with mayonnaise and a little celery, piled into a buttered, griddled top-split roll. The dish to eat here, and the three places that do it best. Recipe at chefamazing.com/food-travel/dish/the-hamptons.
Save this list in Chef Amazing- 1
Lunch (The Lobster Roll)
Napeague, AmagansettGet: The lobster roll
The Infatuation names it the best lobster roll in the Hamptons: mayo-heavy, with chopped celery. The roadside shack opened its 2026 season on April 24.
Also on the list: Long lines in the Hamptons.
- 2
Duryea's Lobster Deck
MontaukGet: The lobster roll on the deck at sunset
A Fort Pond Bay dock and seafood market that many call the best roll out east, walk-in only and seasonal from mid-May.
- 3
Bostwick's Chowder House
East HamptonGet: The lobster roll, hot or cold, and a cup of chowder
The Infatuation calls its roll the most consistent and most accessible. It opened its 2026 season on March 26, 277 Pantigo Road.
Also on the list: Long lines in the Hamptons.
Keep the places you love
Chef Amazing remembers every place you've eaten, booked or been told about, by city, and tells you what to order. Save this list, add your own, and send it to a friend.
Save this list, freeChef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.
Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms