The viral places people queue for, what to get when you reach the front, how long the wait usually is, and how to beat it. Waits are typical, not live.
Save this list in Chef AmazingGet: The lobster roll
The roadside shack The Infatuation calls the best lobster roll in the Hamptons, back each April. Expect: A line on summer weekends, no reservations. Beat it: Get there before 12:30, or go on a weekday.
Also on the list: The best lobster roll in the Hamptons.
Get: The lobster roll and the fish tacos
Paper plates and long waits are part of the deal, reviewers call its roll the most reliable out east. Expect: 45 minutes to an hour after 1pm in summer, no reservations. Beat it: Arrive before noon.
Also on the list: The best lobster roll in the Hamptons.
Get: The pancakes
Eight counter seats in a diner car, the most talked-about opening of 2026. Expect: Up to an hour in early summer 2026, daytime is walk-in only. Beat it: Go right at opening on a weekday, or book dinner on Resy.
Get: Lobster salad by the pound
The 1980 market whose $100-a-pound lobster salad is the Hamptons status picnic. Expect: A line out the door on summer weekends. Beat it: Go early in the week, it was listed as closed Monday and Tuesday.
Get: Homemade ice cream: Oreo mint, toasted coconut or coffee
Open since 1967 on Montauk Highway, making its own ice cream and soft serve. Expect: Long lines on summer nights, cash only. Beat it: Bring cash and go mid-afternoon.
Also on the list: Where to get ice cream in the Hamptons.
Chef Amazing remembers every place you've eaten, booked or been told about, by city, and tells you what to order. Save this list, add your own, and send it to a friend.
Save this list, freeChef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.
Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms