‹ Takeout and delivery › New York › Pizza
New York · checked November 10, 2026
The best pizza delivery and takeout in New York
The 5 places in New York we'd order pizza from tonight. Start with Rubirosa (tie-dye pie, thin-crust pies, chicken parm), then Scarr's Pizza (pepperoni round pie, plain cheese pie, slices), then Mama's Too (pepperoni square, cacio e pepe pie).
1
Rubirosa
Get: Tie-dye pie, thin-crust pies, chicken parm
Thin-crust pies hold their shape in the box, and the vodka sauce stays rich on the ride. Add the chicken parm if you want something for the next day.
Good to know: Order pickup on Toast to skip the delivery markup. It also takes phone and DoorDash orders.
Where we found it: DoorDash: Rubirosa Pizza & Ristorante storefront (reviews through Jan 2026) (2026-01) · Toast: Rubirosa online ordering
2
Scarr's Pizza
Get: Pepperoni round pie, plain cheese pie, slices
Old-school New York pies made with house-milled flour, sturdy enough for a bag. Start with the plain cheese or the pepperoni.
Good to know: Order on its own ordering page, and check it for tonight's hours.
Where we found it: Scarr's Pizza online ordering (Sauce) · The Infatuation: Where To Get Pizza Delivery In NYC
3
Mama's Too
Get: Pepperoni square, cacio e pepe pie
Thick square slices stay crisp underneath in a box. The pepperoni square is the one to order.
Good to know: Pickup is the safer bet. Check mamastoo.com to see if delivery is on tonight.
Where we found it: The Infatuation: Where To Get Pizza Delivery In NYC · Time Out: Mama's Too
4A photo like it
Prince Street Pizza
Get: Spicy Spring square, plain square
Thick Sicilian squares with a crisp base that reheat well at home. The spicy pepperoni square is the one to get.
Good to know: Delivery coverage varies by address, so check yours before you order.
Where we found it: Uber Eats: Prince St Pizza NYC · Prince Street Pizza site
5A photo like it
L'Industrie Pizzeria
Get: Burrata slice, plain slice, whole pie
Thin Neapolitan-style slices that pack flat and eat fine at room temperature. The burrata slice is the one to order.
Good to know: Check the app for tonight's delivery hours.
Where we found it: The Infatuation: L'Industrie Pizzeria West Village · Franki: L'Industrie West Village
Good to know
What is the best pizza delivery in New York?
Rubirosa in Nolita. Get tie-dye pie, thin-crust pies, chicken parm. Thin-crust pies hold their shape in the box, and the vodka sauce stays rich on the ride. Add the chicken parm if you want something for the next day.
Where can I get pizza takeout in New York tonight?
Chef Amazing's list for New York: Rubirosa (Nolita), Scarr's Pizza (Lower East Side), Mama's Too (Upper West Side), Prince Street Pizza (Nolita), L'Industrie Pizzeria (West Village). Each one does takeout or delivery; order from the place's own site when it has one.
Pizza in other cities
How we pick: our own stories and guides first, then this year's critics and best-of lists; every place checked open and checked to do takeout or delivery. Photos marked "a photo like it" show the food, not that place's. Delivery areas and hours change; check before you order. Chef Amazing is not paid by any place on this page.
Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.
Our founder's story · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms