Pick a Side · Rome

Is it still cacio e pepe if you add butter?

Cacio e pepeCacio e pepeA photo like it

Photo: Popo le Chien / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Cacio e pepe is cheese, pepper and pasta. That's it, that's the name. So when a British recipe site added butter and Parmesan, Rome treated it like someone had parked a scooter on the Spanish Steps.

Whose side are you on?

In this corner

Team Three Ingredients

Pecorino, pepper, pasta water. Done.

Rome's version has no butter, no Parmesan and certainly no cream. The creaminess comes from starchy pasta water and finely grated Pecorino Romano whisked into a paste. Add anything else and you've made a different dish.

And in this corner

Team Little Insurance

A knob of butter never hurt anybody.

Pecorino clumps the second it gets too hot, and plenty of home cooks (and a few chefs) add butter or a little Parmesan so the sauce stays silky. Their point: a dinner that works beats a dinner that's correct.

You're . See where Chef lands below.

What's happening now

In August 2025 BBC Good Food published a cacio e pepe with butter and Parmesan. Rome's restaurant association said the dish has no butter, no Parmesan and no cream, one restaurateur said what they'd made was pasta Alfredo, and the row reached the British ambassador.

Chef's call

Learn the three-ingredient version. The secret isn't butter, it's heat: make the cheese into a paste with warm water and mix it into the pasta off the stove. Do that and you'll never need the safety net.

Cacio e pepe, the Roman way

20 min · serves 2 · Chef's recipe

You need

How to make it

  1. Grate the cheese first and let it come to room temperature in a large mixing bowl. Cold cheese is what clumps.
  2. Crack the peppercorns coarsely in a mortar or under a heavy pan. Toast them in a dry wide skillet over medium heat for 1 to 2 minutes, until fragrant, then turn off the heat.
  3. Bring about 2 liters (2 quarts) of water to a boil, less than usual so the water gets starchy. Salt it lightly and cook the pasta 2 minutes short of the package time.
  4. While the pasta cooks, ladle 3 to 4 tablespoons of the cooking water into the cheese and stir with a fork into a thick, smooth paste, like loose ricotta. If it's stiff, add a spoonful more. Let the water cool a minute before you add it; too hot and the cheese seizes.
  5. Add a ladle of pasta water to the pepper skillet and bring it to a simmer. Lift the pasta straight in with tongs and toss over medium heat for 1 to 2 minutes, adding splashes of water, until it's just al dente and glossy.
  6. Take the pan off the heat and wait 30 seconds. Tip the pasta into the bowl with the cheese paste (or the paste into the pan) and toss hard with tongs, adding pasta water a tablespoon at a time, until the sauce turns creamy and coats every strand. It should flow, not sit in clumps.
  7. Serve right away in warm bowls with more pepper and a little extra pecorino on top. It waits for no one.

Good to know, whichever team you're on

Save it and it opens in Chef Amazing with a timeline, mise en place and what you already have.

More sides to pick

CarbonaraCarbonara
Does cream belong in carbonara?Italy's agriculture minister has opinions. So does Heinz.
Team EggTeam Cream
Hawaiian pizzaHawaiian pizza
Is Hawaiian pizza really pizza?It's Canadian, it was invented by a Greek, and a chef just lost a court case over it.
Team NeverTeam Pineapple
Texas chiliTexas chili
Is it still chili if it has beans?In Texas, beans in your chili can get you disqualified.
Team Bowl of RedTeam Beans
Scones with jam and clotted creamScones with jam and clotted cream
Jam first or cream first?Two English counties, one scone, and no plans to compromise.
Team Jam First (Cornwall)Team Cream First (Devon)
Spanish tortillaSpanish tortilla
Does a Spanish tortilla need onion?Spain's longest-running argument has its own words: concebollistas and sincebollistas.
Team OnionTeam No Onion
Chicken tikka masalaChicken tikka masala
Is chicken tikka masala Scottish?Britain's favorite curry has two birth certificates.
Team GlasgowTeam India
All 9 fightsThe viral recipe, testedThe classicsThe 100 most popular recipesChef Amazing

How we built this: every fight comes from current reporting, with the sources under it (checked November 19, 2026). Both teams get their say, and Chef's call is a favorite, not a ruling. The recipes are Chef's own write-ups. Photos are from Wikimedia Commons, credited at the foot of the page; "a photo like it" means it isn't from anyone named here.

Photo credits

Commons photos are used under the licenses linked; changes: resized or cropped.

Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.

Researched and published by Chef Amazing, from our own stories, this year’s critics and food press, and a check that each place is open. Nobody pays to be on our lists: how we pick. Spot something wrong? Tell us and we fix it.

About us · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms