Pick a Side · New England vs. New York

Is Manhattan clam chowder really chowder?

Clam chowderClam chowderA photo like it

Photo: Jen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

New England clam chowder is creamy and white. Manhattan clam chowder is red, with tomatoes and no cream. New Englanders have been saying the red one isn't chowder at all for almost a hundred years.

Whose side are you on?

In this corner

Team New England

Clams, potatoes, salt pork, milk or cream.

Chowder has been made in New England since the 1700s, and it's white: clam broth, salt pork, potatoes and dairy. Tomatoes, they say, turn it into vegetable soup.

And in this corner

Team Manhattan

Bright, lighter, and you can actually taste the clams.

The red version, made with tomatoes and no cream, caught on in New York in the early 1900s, probably thanks to the city's Portuguese and Italian cooks. It's lighter and brinier and plenty of people prefer it.

You're . See where Chef lands below.

What's happening now

In 1939 Maine state representative Cleveland Sleeper drafted a bill to ban tomatoes in chowder and called the Manhattan version vegetable soup. It never became law: a chowder cook-off was held instead, and New England-style won. There's still no law against it in Maine today.

Chef's call

New England, but not the gluey kind. Real chowder is brothy and only lightly thickened, and it's even better the second day. Manhattan is a great soup; we'd just never fight a New Englander over what to call it.

New England clam chowder

1 hour · serves 6 · Chef's recipe

You need

How to make it

  1. Put the clams in a large pot with 3 cups of water. Cover and boil over high heat for 6 to 10 minutes, shaking the pot, until they open. Lift them out as they open; throw away any that stay shut.
  2. Pour the broth through a sieve lined with a paper towel to catch any sand. You should have about 4 cups; top up with water or bottled clam juice if not. Pull the clams from their shells and chop them coarsely. Keep a few in the shell for the top.
  3. In a clean heavy pot, cook the salt pork over medium-low heat for 8 to 10 minutes until crisp and the fat has rendered. Lift out half the crisp bits for garnish.
  4. Add the butter, onion and celery and cook gently for 8 minutes until soft but not brown. Add the garlic for 1 minute, then sprinkle in the flour and stir 2 minutes.
  5. Whisk in the clam broth slowly so it stays smooth. Add the potatoes, thyme and bay. Simmer 12 to 15 minutes, until the potatoes are tender. Press a few against the side of the pot to thicken the broth a little.
  6. Lower the heat, add the milk and cream and warm through without boiling (boiling can make it split). Add the chopped clams for the last 2 minutes only, or they turn rubbery.
  7. Season with pepper (taste before adding any salt; the clams and pork are salty). Serve topped with the crisp pork, herbs, a few clams in the shell and oyster crackers.

Good to know, whichever team you're on

Save it and it opens in Chef Amazing with a timeline, mise en place and what you already have.

More sides to pick

Cacio e pepeCacio e pepe
Is it still cacio e pepe if you add butter?Three ingredients. One stick of butter. An international incident.
Team Three IngredientsTeam Little Insurance
CarbonaraCarbonara
Does cream belong in carbonara?Italy's agriculture minister has opinions. So does Heinz.
Team EggTeam Cream
Hawaiian pizzaHawaiian pizza
Is Hawaiian pizza really pizza?It's Canadian, it was invented by a Greek, and a chef just lost a court case over it.
Team NeverTeam Pineapple
Texas chiliTexas chili
Is it still chili if it has beans?In Texas, beans in your chili can get you disqualified.
Team Bowl of RedTeam Beans
Scones with jam and clotted creamScones with jam and clotted cream
Jam first or cream first?Two English counties, one scone, and no plans to compromise.
Team Jam First (Cornwall)Team Cream First (Devon)
Spanish tortillaSpanish tortilla
Does a Spanish tortilla need onion?Spain's longest-running argument has its own words: concebollistas and sincebollistas.
Team OnionTeam No Onion
All 9 fightsThe viral recipe, testedThe classicsThe 100 most popular recipesChef Amazing

How we built this: every fight comes from current reporting, with the sources under it (checked November 19, 2026). Both teams get their say, and Chef's call is a favorite, not a ruling. The recipes are Chef's own write-ups. Photos are from Wikimedia Commons, credited at the foot of the page; "a photo like it" means it isn't from anyone named here.

Photo credits

Commons photos are used under the licenses linked; changes: resized or cropped.

Chef Amazing remembers every place you ate, keeps the lists friends send you, and helps you cook it at home.

Researched and published by Chef Amazing, from our own stories, this year’s critics and food press, and a check that each place is open. Nobody pays to be on our lists: how we pick. Spot something wrong? Tell us and we fix it.

About us · For chefs and food creators · Privacy · Terms